How to achieve diverse EU forest policy objectives?
Stakeholder preferences on policy implementation using land sparing or sharing approaches under different future scenariosAbstract
The forest policy landscape is dominated by contrasting ambitions and targets, with large inconsistencies between EU targets, national targets, conflicting stakeholder interests, and the implementation by landowners, who ultimately take the management decisions. To explore options for resolving these inconsistencies, authors organised a workshop with stakeholders from six European countries (BG, DE, ES, PL, SE, SI). Under three different future policy scenarios, they presented strategies to spatially implement different policy targets using the concepts of land sparing, land sharing and triad. During the workshop, stakeholders were asked how alternative policy scenarios could be most effectively achieved considering the different national contexts. The cross-country comparison enabled the examination of differences in national preferences, including how to distribute biodiversity protection commitments and spatially allocate additional forest reserves. Generally, stakeholders across countries considered land sharing the most effective strategy to implement both biodiversity and economic goals for forest management. Spain, Sweden and Poland preferred land sparing, particularly for implementing bioeconomy-focused goals. This trend was most pronounced in countries with remote forest areas with a low population density. The main identified barriers to implementation across policy objectives were insufficient funding, difficulty triggering behavioural change in private forest owners, insufficient knowledge transfer, and climate change. The European Union's policy goals require consideration on how they may be adapted to the distinct contexts of the diverse socio-economic circumstances and forest management traditions in the member states.
Citation
Haase, M., O'Brien, L., Malovrh, Š.P., Sotirov, M., Lindahl, K.B., Castelli, F., Felton, A., Nieberg, M., Paligorov, I., Pecurul-Botines, M., Tymińska-Czabańska, L., Uhan, Z., Lindner, M. (2026) How to achieve diverse EU forest policy objectives? Stakeholder preferences on policy implementation using land sparing or sharing approaches under different future scenarios. Forest Policy and Economics 193, 103956. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forpol.2026.103956.
Related content
What comes after the European Green Deal?
A multidisciplinary look at what could follow the EU Green Deal, assessing risks, setbacks and pathways for future land‑use and conservation policy.
- Inclusive governance
Designing better support for forest owners: business models & policy tools for sustainability
This workshop is a practical and participatory discussion about what would actually work in Finland in the field of sustainable forest management.
9 December 2026, 09:00–13:00
- Co-created solutions
What needs to happen for Europe’s forests to deliver on the 2050 climate and biodiversity goals?
Europe’s forests are central to reaching the EU’s climate and biodiversity goals for 2050. But what will it actually take to get there?
17 November 2026, 10:00–12:15, CET
- Co-created solutions